Print this page.

REGROWTH

Control of Bacterial Regrowth in Water supply Distribution Systems in Water Short European and Mediterranean Countries.

NUMBER: IC18-CT-1997-0136
Start Date: 01/11/1997 End Date: 30/04/2001
SUMMARY: (08/03/2001)

Three Mediterranean countries subject to Intermittent Water Supplies and two European countries with Continuous Water Supplies are collaborating in this project. The aim of the project has been to identify situations in water distribution systems in each country where bacterial regrowth can be demonstrated, to determine the extent of regrowth whether or not it constitutes a threat to public health, and ultimately to model the water distribution systems in terms of hydraulic, conservative and non- conservative chemical parameters, and bacteria (based on Heterotrophic Plate Counts), and use these models to examine various control scenarios to limit the extent of bacterial regrowth.

Water distribution systems in each country have been selected and the necessary information gathered to model the systems hydraulic, physical and chemical behaviour using the Epanet public domaine package published by EPA. The more sophisticated Performance Q event-driven model developed by our Portuguese partner has been interfaced with Epanet, and Performance Q has been expanded to enable growth, death and detachment to be modelled. The whole has been encapsulated in an MS –Windows based easy to use shell. The Enhanced performance Q model is now in the final stages of testing.

The data collected by the partner organisations is clearly pointing to the situations which enhance bacterial growth, namely systems in which TOC > 5mg/l (usually surface water sources) with temperatures of 15oC or above, systems with long retention times (long mains, service reservoirs, and household storage tanks in countries with intermittent water supplies), and low (<0.3mg/l) chlorine concentrations. Variable velocity due to fluctuating water demand also has the effect of detaching biofilm from pipe walls, causing sudden increases in suspended bacterial numbers.

When water pumping starts after a period of no flow in an intermittent supply, poor water quality has been shown to occur due to infiltration of contaminated water and/or detachment of biofilm from the pipes.

A clear potential health risk has been demonstrated in household water storage tanks, where bacterial increases of up to 5 orders of magnitude may occur in surface derived waters over a seven day period.

EXPECTED RESULTS:

The project is expected to highlight the microbial water quality problems related to intermittent water supplies, particularly in relation to deterioration of water quality in household water storage tanks, and poor quality in the first flush after a period of no flow, due to infiltration and/or biofilm sloughing.

Three distribution systems in Mediterranean counties subject to intermittent water flows and two distribution systems in UK and Portugal subject to continuous water flows have been studied to produce Epanet models which can predict chlorine concentrations. A refinement of these models known as Enhanced Performance Q has been developed in Portugal, to predict bacterial numbers and give more sophisticated chlorine predictions, and a simple plug flow model has been developed in Newcastle to predict bacterial numbers.It is expected that the predictions will match very well with the results of surveys in the case of the continuous systems, but will be more poorly correlated for the intermittent distribution systems due to the problems mentioned above. Ultimately the Performance Q model will be used to examine and evaluate bacterial growth scenarios.

Kinetic coefficients of growth and death of bacterial isolates and of opportunistic pathogens from distribution systems have been measured and included in the models. Also bulk and wall chlorine decay coefficients have been measured and used in the models.

Laboratory rig studies in Jordan and Portugal are being used to measure rates of growth and detachment of biofilm.

Household water storage tanks studies are demonstrating several orders of magnitude of bacterial growth when surface waters are stored in the presence of low or zero chlorine concentrations for 4-7days.

ACHIEVED RESULTS: (08/03/2001)

1. Monitoring distribution networks in each country for hydraulic, chemical and bacterial parameters.
2. Hydraulic calibration and validation of Epanet models for each network.
3. Determination of kinetic coefficients of growth and death of relevant bacteria, plus chlorine decay kinetics in bulk and wall effects.
4. Behaviour of bacteria in household storage tanks.
5. Biofilm measurement of growth and detachment from pipes.
6. Demonstration of infiltration in two intermittent water distribution systems.
7. Epidemiological study on populations using untreated water sources.
8. Formulation and evaluation of Enhanced Performance Q model.
9. Formulation and validation of plug flow model of bacterial growth and death.

AVAILABLE DOCUMENTS:
  • Evison, L. and Sunna,N. (2001) Microbial Regrowth in Household Storage Tanks. JAWWA Vol 93 (4)
  • Hashwa, F. and Tokajian, S. (2000) Change of Water Quality in the Distribution System of a Residential Area in Beirut. Presented to IVth International Conference on Water Supply and Water Quality, Krakow, Poland, 11-13th September 2000.
  • Menaia, J., Alves, R., Mesquita, E., and Tarvares, J.T. (2000) Protein Contents as a Measure of the Active Biomass in Monitoring Drinking Water Pipe Biofilm Colonisation. Submitted for publication in Water Science and Technology.
  • Tokajian, S., Sunna, N., Evison,L., and Hashwa, F. (2000) Microbial Regrowth in Household Tanks. Poster paper, 1st World Congress of the International Water Association (IWA), Paris, 3-7th July 2000.
  • Vieira, P. and Coelho, S.T. (2000) Chlorine Decay in Water Distribution Systems.5th Water Congress, Lisbon, Portugal, April 2000.
URL: -
TOPICS 6100 Modelling & Optimisation, 1700 Water pollution, 1200 Water Quality Control, 1610 Collection, storage, distribution
KEYWORDS biofilm, household_storage, epidemiology
 
Contact involved parties directly